Friday, November 20, 2026

The Republic That Builds Monuments but Cannot Respect Books

The Central Secretariat Library controversy exposes India's misplaced priorities, the neglect of public institutions and a disturbing retreat from the culture of reading. A nation that fails to preserve its intellectual inheritance risks impoverishing generations that have yet to be born.

By: Ramphal Kataria

(An article on libraries, intellectual freedom, historical preservation and the declining culture of reading)

“A government may demolish an old building and construct a new capital, but it cannot reconstruct a civilisation's memory once its books, manuscripts and historical records have been allowed to disappear.”

The allocation of 4,000 square metres to the 135-year-old Central Secretariat Library (CSL) in Delhi's Netaji Nagar government complex is, undoubtedly, better than the earlier proposal to accommodate its enormous collection in two rooms measuring barely 300 square metres. Yet, the circumstances in which this allocation has finally materialised are deeply disturbing. An institution preserving 8.5 lakh books, rare manuscripts, historical government publications, administrative records and documents of immense national importance should never have had to depend upon judicial intervention to secure adequate accommodation.

The Supreme Court's intervention has brought an uncomfortable truth into public view: in a country that frequently invokes its civilisational heritage, books and institutions preserving historical knowledge do not always receive the respect, financial commitment or administrative priority they deserve.

The issue is considerably larger than the relocation of a government library. It concerns the value that a society attaches to knowledge, the responsibility of the State towards its intellectual inheritance, and the kind of citizens a nation hopes to produce.

The Central Secretariat Library is not merely a collection of old books occupying government premises. It is a repository of India's administrative memory. Its records preserve the evolution of governance, law, public policy, revenue administration, census operations, land settlements and the institutional foundations of modern India. Its oldest rare collection includes a French work dating back to 1702, while its holdings contain historical administrative publications, including an 1874 account of Lord Ellenborough's administration.

These are not obsolete papers awaiting disposal. They are primary historical sources through which future researchers can understand how the country was administered, how its institutions evolved, how its people were governed and how the foundations of contemporary India were laid.

The Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs has now allocated approximately 4,000 square metres at Netaji Nagar, following the earlier inadequate proposal of 300 square metres at Kartavya Bhawan-2. The Ministry of Culture had sought approximately 5,466 square metres, while the library currently occupies around 5,500 square metres according to the reported figures. The difference is not merely a question of floor area. It raises questions about storage capacity, accessibility, preservation infrastructure, reading facilities and the future expansion of the collection.

The Supreme Court had to take suo motu cognisance of the matter after reports brought the library's uncertain future to its attention. Its observations about the need to show respect to books were a timely reminder to the administration that public infrastructure cannot be evaluated exclusively through construction schedules, commercial contracts and the speed with which old buildings can be cleared.

A library is not an obstacle to development. It is one of the purposes for which development must exist.

1. A library that carries the memory of a nation

The Imperial Secretariat Library was established in Calcutta in 1891, during British rule. It was conceived as a central repository of official publications, administrative literature, government reports and reference material required by the colonial administration. Over time, its holdings expanded through the incorporation of collections from different pre-Independence institutions.

When the British government shifted the capital from Calcutta to Delhi in 1911, the library also moved. It initially operated from the Old Secretariat in Civil Lines, subsequently shifted to North Block and eventually found its home in Shastri Bhavan in 1969. Following Independence, it came to be known as the Central Secretariat Library and functioned under the Ministry of Culture.

Its original purpose was closely associated with the informational requirements of the central administration. The library provided government officials and policymakers access to legislative documents, historical records, gazetteers, administrative reports and published research. This was essential in a period when government departments depended upon printed documents and institutional records to understand earlier decisions, formulate policies and administer a vast country.

However, the significance of the library gradually transcended its original administrative purpose. It became a resource for historians, researchers, academicians, students and other members of the public.

Today, its collection comprises approximately 8.5 lakh volumes, including books, government publications, reports, gazettes and other documentary material. It also preserves more than 5,000 rare titles. Among its remarkable holdings are a 1702 French work associated with voyages involving the East India Company, nineteenth-century administrative publications, settlement reports, census records, Acts of Parliament and government gazettes.

These documents are particularly important because historical understanding cannot rest entirely upon secondary interpretations. A historian writing about colonial land revenue administration, for example, must examine original settlement reports. A researcher studying demographic change needs historical census records. An academic analysing the evolution of Indian legislation requires access to the original Acts, notifications and administrative correspondence.

A library of this nature therefore performs a function that cannot be replaced by a collection of newly published books.

It preserves not merely what people have written about history, but the original evidence from which history itself can be reconstructed.

The actual readership: A resource that must be used, not merely preserved

An important aspect of the Central Secretariat Library's significance is its actual use by readers.

According to the Ministry of Culture's Annual Report for 2023–24, approximately 33,871 users visited the library during 2023. Around 5,189 books were issued or returned through its lending services, while approximately 35,190 books and other publications were consulted across its different units during the reporting period.

These figures deserve attention. They demonstrate that the library is not simply a government storehouse for historical material. It continues to serve an identifiable community of readers and researchers.

Its readership includes government officials, policy planners, research scholars, academicians and students, including those preparing for competitive examinations.

The figures also raise another important question: how can an institution holding 8.5 lakh publications be made more accessible to a much larger readership?

The answer cannot be limited to shifting its collection from one building to another. The library needs a comprehensive modernisation programme, improved cataloguing, digital access, research facilities, preservation laboratories, extended reading services and active public engagement.

Relocation should become an opportunity to transform the institution, not merely an administrative exercise to accommodate its books somewhere else.

2. The origins of libraries: Humanity's earliest investment in collective memory

The history of libraries is almost as old as the history of organised human civilisation. Long before the invention of printing, societies understood that knowledge, if not preserved, would disappear with the death of those who possessed it.

The earliest known organised collections of written records emerged in ancient Mesopotamia and Egypt. Temples, palaces and administrative establishments maintained clay tablets recording commercial transactions, taxation, agricultural production, legal decisions, religious practices and astronomical observations.

Archaeological evidence establishes that organised collections of texts existed in the ancient Near East as early as the third millennium BCE. These were not libraries in the modern democratic sense, but they performed an essential function: preserving information beyond the lifetime of individuals and making it available to successive generations of scribes and scholars.

One of the most remarkable examples was the Library of Ashurbanipal at Nineveh, established in the seventh century BCE under the Assyrian ruler Ashurbanipal. Its collection contained thousands of clay tablets, including literary works, religious texts, scientific observations and administrative records.

The discovery of the library's remains provided historians with invaluable material for understanding ancient Mesopotamian civilisation. Among its most celebrated texts was the Epic of Gilgamesh, one of humanity's oldest surviving literary works.

The collection demonstrated something fundamental: rulers who understood the value of knowledge invested in preserving it, even when that knowledge was not immediately useful for warfare, taxation or administration.

The ancient Library of Alexandria, established under the Ptolemaic rulers in Egypt during the third century BCE, represented another extraordinary development. It sought to collect the literary and scholarly works of the known world. Scholars associated with Alexandria worked on mathematics, astronomy, geography, medicine, philosophy, literature and textual criticism.

The library was associated with the Museum of Alexandria, an institution devoted to scholarship and intellectual exchange. It became a centre where scholars could study, compare manuscripts, debate ideas and produce new knowledge.

Its historical importance lies not simply in the number of scrolls it accumulated, but in its ambition to make the intellectual achievements of different societies available within one scholarly institution.

Although the popular story that a single catastrophic fire destroyed the entire Library of Alexandria is historically disputed, the gradual loss of its collections remains one of the enduring tragedies in the history of knowledge.

The lesson is unmistakable: knowledge accumulated over centuries can disappear within a relatively short period when institutions fail to protect it.

Libraries and the making of modern civilisation

The contribution of libraries to civilisation cannot be measured merely by the number of books preserved.

They enabled societies to accumulate knowledge, challenge inherited assumptions, compare competing explanations and build upon the intellectual achievements of earlier generations.

The preservation and transmission of Greek philosophy, Roman law, mathematics, medicine, astronomy and literature through manuscript traditions helped shape later intellectual developments.

During the medieval period, institutions such as the House of Wisdom in Baghdad became centres of translation, scientific inquiry and intellectual exchange. Greek, Persian and Indian works were translated into Arabic, studied, criticised and expanded upon. Scholars working in this wider intellectual world made important contributions to mathematics, astronomy, medicine, optics and philosophy.

Libraries and manuscript collections associated with monasteries, universities, courts and religious institutions also helped preserve knowledge during periods of political instability and social upheaval.

The development of printing in Europe in the fifteenth century transformed the scale and speed of knowledge dissemination. Books became progressively more accessible, universities expanded, scientific publications circulated and the reading public widened.

The Enlightenment, the scientific revolution and the growth of modern democratic institutions were not products of libraries alone. They emerged from complex social, economic and political changes. Yet libraries provided the intellectual infrastructure through which ideas could travel, be scrutinised and acquire influence.

A scientific discovery could be challenged by another scholar because its findings were recorded and circulated. A political philosopher could question monarchy because earlier political thought was accessible. A citizen could understand the relationship between government and individual rights because the written record of political argument had accumulated across generations.

The greatest contribution of a library is that it allows one generation to begin where the previous generation stopped thinking.

3. India's library tradition: From ancient repositories to public institutions

India possesses a remarkable history of knowledge preservation. Its traditions of learning developed through gurukuls, Buddhist monasteries, Jain institutions, temple establishments, royal courts, scholarly centres and manuscript repositories.

The ancient universities of Takshashila, Nalanda and Vikramashila represented sophisticated centres of education and intellectual exchange. Nalanda, in particular, attracted students and scholars from different parts of Asia.

The Chinese Buddhist traveller Xuanzang, who studied at Nalanda in the seventh century, recorded the scale of its scholarly activity and the extensive intellectual resources available there.

Traditional accounts associate Nalanda with large manuscript collections, including the celebrated library complex sometimes referred to as Ratnasagara, Ratnodadhi and Ratnaranjaka. Its destruction during the medieval period resulted in the loss of an enormous body of accumulated knowledge.

It would be historically simplistic to attribute the disappearance of India's intellectual inheritance to a single event. Repeated invasions, political instability, institutional decline, environmental deterioration and the vulnerability of manuscript materials all contributed to the loss of collections over centuries.

Nevertheless, the destruction of major centres of learning illustrates the fragility of knowledge institutions when their protection is not treated as a civilisational responsibility.

The emergence of historic libraries in modern India

India's modern library tradition developed through a combination of royal patronage, scholarly societies, colonial administrative requirements and public initiatives.

Some of the country's most important historic libraries are worth recalling.

1. Rampur Raza Library — 1774

Founded by Nawab Faizullah Khan, it is a remarkable repository of Indo-Islamic learning, with approximately 17,000 manuscripts, rare illustrated works, paintings, calligraphy and around 65,000 printed books. Its holdings span Arabic, Persian, Sanskrit, Urdu, Hindi and other languages.

2. The Asiatic Society Library — 1784

Founded by Sir William Jones, the Asiatic Society became an important centre for the study of Asian languages, history, archaeology, philosophy and literature. Its library contains more than 1.34 lakh books and 1.09 lakh bound journal volumes, besides manuscripts and rare collections.

3. Sarasvati Mahal Library — Nayak period

Originating as Saraswati Bhandar during the reign of the Nayak rulers of Thanjavur, it was enriched by successive Maratha rulers, particularly Maharaja Serfoji II. It preserves palm-leaf manuscripts, ancient books, maps and paintings, representing a remarkable continuity of South Indian scholarship.

4. Khuda Bakhsh Oriental Public Library — 1891

Established by Khan Bahadur Khuda Bakhsh, who donated his inherited and personal collection to the public, it opened with approximately 4,000 manuscripts. It now holds around 21,000 Oriental manuscripts and a substantial collection of printed books. It was declared an Institution of National Importance in 1969.

5. National Library of India — 1836 (institutional origins)

Its institutional history begins with the Calcutta Public Library, established on 21 March 1836. This was later amalgamated with the Imperial Secretariat Library to form the Imperial Library in 1902. Following Independence, it became the National Library under the Imperial Library (Change of Name) Act, 1948, and was opened to the public on 1 February 1953. It serves as the country's principal repository of published material.

6. Connemara Public Library — 1896

Its foundation stone was laid in 1890, and it opened on 5 December 1896. It became a State Central Library in 1950 and is one of India's four national depository libraries. Its collection exceeds nine lakh books across several Indian languages and English.

7. Central Secretariat Library — 1891

Originally the Imperial Secretariat Library in Calcutta, it developed into one of India's major government research libraries, with approximately 8.5 lakh books and official publications.

These institutions represent different traditions of knowledge preservation. Some emerged from royal patronage, some from scholarly societies, others from private philanthropy and government initiatives.

Their common characteristic is that individuals and institutions understood that knowledge should survive beyond the immediate interests of the generation that accumulated it.

The National Library and India's largest library collection

The National Library of India in Kolkata is the country's principal national repository and, by its institutional status and collection, the largest library in India.

Its origins in the Calcutta Public Library of 1836 make it one of the oldest major public library traditions in the country. Following its transformation into the Imperial Library and subsequently the National Library, it assumed responsibility for collecting and preserving publications produced in India.

Under the Delivery of Books and Newspapers (Public Libraries) Act, 1954, it receives publications covered by the legislation. Its responsibilities therefore extend beyond serving individual readers: it preserves the country's published intellectual output for future generations.

The Connemara Public Library performs a similar depository function for Indian publications, while institutions such as the Asiatic Society, Rampur Raza Library and Khuda Bakhsh Oriental Public Library preserve specialised collections that are often impossible to reconstruct elsewhere.

The importance of these libraries cannot be judged exclusively by their numerical holdings. A manuscript available nowhere else in the world may be more historically significant than thousands of ordinary printed volumes.

A nation's intellectual wealth is not determined by how many books it owns, but by how much knowledge it preserves, makes accessible and puts to use.

4. Public libraries and the democratisation of knowledge

The most important development in the history of libraries was the transition from private and institutional collections to public libraries.

For centuries, access to books was largely determined by wealth, social position, religious affiliation and proximity to centres of learning. Manuscripts were expensive to produce, literacy was limited and knowledge remained concentrated among privileged sections of society.

The emergence of public libraries challenged this arrangement.

A public library makes knowledge available without requiring an individual to purchase every book, subscribe to expensive journals or belong to an elite academic institution. It allows a poor student to access the same reference material as a wealthy student, a worker to read about science and history, and an ordinary citizen to understand the laws and institutions governing the country.

This is perhaps one of the most democratic functions of a modern State.

A public library is not merely a welfare facility. It is an institution that reduces the inequality of access to knowledge.

A child born into a financially disadvantaged household may not have a personal collection of books, a computer or an educated family member to guide their intellectual development. A well-equipped public library can provide access to all three elements: books, information resources and a learning environment.

Similarly, a young person preparing for competitive examinations should not have to depend upon expensive coaching centres or costly reference material simply because their family cannot afford them.

Libraries can provide an alternative.

They also serve people who are no longer in formal education. A farmer can access agricultural information, a small entrepreneur can study business management, a woman can learn about her legal rights, and an elderly person can continue intellectual pursuits long after retirement.

This is why public libraries must be considered essential social infrastructure, comparable in importance to schools, hospitals and community centres.

India's public library movement

The development of public libraries in India gathered momentum during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Several princely states and provincial administrations supported libraries, while social reformers and voluntary organisations promoted reading among ordinary people.

The Madras Public Libraries Act, 1948, was a landmark in Indian library legislation. It established an organised framework for public library services in the then Madras State. It was followed by library legislation in other states.

A particularly important contribution came from Dr S. R. Ranganathan (1892–1972), widely recognised as the father of library science in India.

ieved that libraries should not remain passive warehouses of books. They should actively reach readers, respond to the needs of communities and make knowledge accessible to all sections of society.

His contribution was not restricted to library classification and cataloguing. He championed the public library movement, promoted professional library education and experimented with mobile library services, including taking books to rural communities through bullock-cart libraries.

In 1931, he published The Five Laws of Library Science, which continue to influence librarianship internationally:

1. Books are for use.

2. Every person his or her book.

3. Every book its reader.

4. Save the time of the reader.

5. The library is a growing organism.

These principles remain remarkably relevant.

The first law, in particular, is a direct challenge to the administrative attitude of treating libraries as storage facilities. A book locked away in a cupboard, deteriorating on an inaccessible shelf or lying unidentified in a carton is not fulfilling its purpose.

Ranganathan's philosophy was that a library must organise itself around the reader, not the convenience of the institution.

The University College London, where Ranganathan received his library training, has documented his contribution to the development of modern library services and his efforts to democratise access to books.

How many public libraries does India have?

According to information furnished by the Ministry of Culture in December 2025, India has 46,746 public libraries across its States and Union Territories. The data, compiled through the Raja Rammohun Roy Library Foundation, provides an indication of the geographical spread of the public library network.

However, the number alone is not sufficient to establish the health of the country's public library system.

Consider the distribution reported in the official data:

State

Reported public libraries

Maharashtra

12,191

Kerala

8,415

Karnataka

6,798

Tamil Nadu

4,622

West Bengal

5,251

Gujarat

3,464

Haryana

27

Punjab

15

Source: Ministry of Culture / Raja Rammohun Roy Library Foundation data. These are reported institutional counts, not verified figures for currently operational, adequately staffed or fully equipped libraries.

The contrast is striking. Kerala, Karnataka and Maharashtra have developed extensive public library networks, whereas the reported numbers for Haryana and Punjab are exceptionally low.

The figures should prompt serious examination of the condition of libraries in northern India.

A public library system cannot be considered successful merely because a building has been designated as a library. Its actual value depends on the quality of its collection, the availability of trained staff, opening hours, accessibility, reading facilities, financial support and the number of people who use it.

India needs a comprehensive, periodically updated public library census recording operational status, annual visitors, membership, books issued, digital access, staffing and expenditure.

The National Mission on Libraries and the Raja Rammohun Roy Library Foundation have important responsibilities in this regard. Their programmes should be judged not only by the funds sanctioned or buildings renovated, but by measurable improvements in reading and public access to information.

A library that nobody can access is a public institution in name, not in substance.

5. The world's greatest libraries: What serious investment in knowledge looks like

The international experience offers an important lesson. Countries that have invested in libraries have treated them as permanent institutions of national importance, not temporary administrative arrangements.

1. Library of Congress — United States

Established in 1800, it is generally recognised as the world's largest library by collection. Its FY2024 report records more than 181.1 million items, including over 26 million catalogued books. Its digital platforms recorded 149.3 million visits in FY2024, alongside extensive reference and reader services.

2. British Library — United Kingdom

Its collection exceeds 170 million items, including books, manuscripts, maps, newspapers, sound recordings and historical documents. It is the national library of the United Kingdom and provides free public access to its services.

3. Russian State Library — Russia

One of the world's largest national libraries, with an extensive collection of books, periodicals, manuscripts and other documentary material.

4. National Library of China — China

A major national institution preserving Chinese publications, historical manuscripts and international scholarly material.

5. New York Public Library — United States

An important example of a public library network that combines extensive research collections with neighbourhood libraries, educational programmes and community services.

The figures of the Library of Congress and British Library need to be understood correctly: their total collections include manuscripts, maps, photographs, recordings, digital material and other objects, not merely printed books.

The Library of Congress's 181.1 million items make it the largest by reported collection size in this comparison. Its 149.3 million figure for FY2024 represents visits to its websites, not physical footfall inside its buildings.

The important distinction is that these institutions combine preservation with public service. They do not consider their responsibility fulfilled by accumulating books. They invest in cataloguing, research, conservation, digitisation, exhibitions, educational programmes and access.

India must aspire to the same institutional seriousness.

6. Karl Marx: A revolution conceived in the reading room

Few examples demonstrate the transformative power of books and libraries as vividly as the life of Karl Marx.

Marx was not born into the working-class conditions that later became central to his analysis. He came from a relatively educated family, studied at university and initially pursued an academic career. Political persecution, exile and his radical writings eventually forced him to live as an émigré.

He settled in London in 1849 with his family. The years that followed were marked by financial insecurity, illness, debt and recurring personal tragedy.

His most productive intellectual years were spent studying in the reading room of the British Museum, the institution whose collections later became part of the British Library.

There, Marx immersed himself in the works of classical political economists, historians, philosophers and contemporary researchers. He studied Adam Smith, David Ricardo and a vast body of material on political economy, industrial development, labour, technology and history.

His research helped lay the intellectual foundation for Das Kapital, the first volume of which appeared in 1867.

The significance of this example is extraordinary.

Marx did not develop his economic critique merely through personal observation or political slogans. He spent years examining published material, comparing theories, studying statistics and investigating the historical development of capitalism.

His work was deeply rooted in reading, research, argument and intellectual engagement with the writings of others.

His financial circumstances were often desperate. His friend Friedrich Engels provided sustained financial assistance, without which Marx's research and family life would have been considerably more difficult.

The family suffered devastating losses. Of the seven children born to Marx and his wife Jenny, only three survived to adulthood. The deaths of their children occurred against a background of poverty, illness and inadequate material security.

It would be wrong to romanticise the family's suffering or suggest that intellectual commitment justified their deprivation. The tragedy instead reveals the enormous personal cost of Marx's circumstances and the determination with which he continued his scholarly work.

One need not agree with Marx's political conclusions, economic theories or ideological legacy to recognise the intellectual significance of his method.

He demonstrated that a person could enter a library without wealth or political power and engage with the accumulated knowledge of centuries.

The reading room gave Marx access to the intellectual world; sustained study gave him the tools to challenge the economic order of his own time.

There are other remarkable examples of scholars whose work was inseparable from their engagement with books.

Other intellectuals whose lives were shaped by libraries and books

1. Dr B. R. Ambedkar

Ambedkar's life offers perhaps the most powerful Indian example of education as an instrument of social emancipation.

Born into a socially oppressed community, he confronted discrimination throughout his educational journey. Yet, through extraordinary intellectual discipline, he pursued higher studies at Columbia University and the London School of Economics.

He became a prolific reader and scholar, studying economics, law, political philosophy, history, religion and sociology.

His personal library, Rajgriha, became a symbol of his commitment to books. His enormous collection reflected his conviction that knowledge was indispensable to challenging caste oppression and securing equality.

For Ambedkar, education was not simply a means of personal advancement. It was an instrument for transforming society.

His famous exhortation, "Educate, Agitate, Organise", captured the relationship between knowledge and collective emancipation.

2. Thomas Jefferson

Jefferson's personal collection of 6,487 books became the foundation of the Library of Congress's reconstructed collection after the British burned the Capitol and its original library in 1814.

In 1815, the United States Congress purchased his library. The transaction helped rebuild the institution and demonstrated the importance attached to preserving knowledge even after national catastrophe.

3. Jawaharlal Nehru

Nehru's intellectual development was closely associated with extensive reading in history, philosophy, politics and world affairs. His writings, particularly The Discovery of India, reveal an effort to understand Indian civilisation through historical research and engagement with diverse intellectual traditions.

4. Rabindranath Tagore

Tagore's literary and educational vision was built upon a deep engagement with Indian and international literature, philosophy, music and art. His establishment of Santiniketan and Visva-Bharati reflected his belief that education must transcend narrow institutional boundaries and encourage intellectual freedom.

5. Abraham Lincoln

Lincoln had limited formal schooling but developed his intellectual capacities through determined self-education. He read law, literature, history and political writing, demonstrating how access to books and sustained independent study can transform an individual's intellectual possibilities.

These examples represent different ideological traditions, historical circumstances and educational backgrounds. Their common lesson is that books enable individuals to move beyond the intellectual limitations imposed by their immediate environment.

7. The decline of reading: From the printed page to the scrolling screen

The contemporary crisis of reading deserves serious attention.

For earlier generations, reading books was an important form of recreation, intellectual engagement and self-improvement. People spent evenings reading novels, newspapers, biographies, poetry, history and political literature. Libraries and bookshops were familiar features of urban and educational life.

Books were not merely examination material. They were companions.

The arrival of television gradually changed leisure habits. Later came computers, the internet, smartphones, social media, streaming platforms and web series. Each technological development expanded access to information and entertainment, but collectively they also intensified competition for people's attention.

The problem is not technology itself. Nor is it reasonable to suggest that all visual media are intellectually inferior to books.

Documentaries, educational films, online lectures and digital archives have opened extraordinary opportunities for learning. The internet has made knowledge available on a scale that earlier generations could scarcely imagine.

The concern is the changing nature of engagement with information.

Reading a substantial book requires concentration, patience, sustained attention and the ability to follow a complex argument over many pages. Short videos, scrolling feeds and rapidly changing visual content often encourage a different pattern of consumption: brief engagement, immediate stimulation and frequent switching between subjects.

A person may spend several hours looking at a screen and still have difficulty recalling what they encountered.

Information consumption is not necessarily knowledge acquisition.

India's shrinking leisure-reading habit

A particularly concerning finding emerged from the National Council of Applied Economic Research (NCAER) in February 2026.

An analysis by Palash Baruah and D. L. Wankhar, based on India's Time Use Survey, reported that the proportion of people engaging in leisure reading fell from 5.4 per cent in 2019 to 4 per cent in 2024.

The authors highlighted how long working hours, commuting and the easy availability of mobile-phone distractions have reduced the time available for leisure reading.

This finding deserves more attention than it has received.

It suggests that the decline in reading is not merely a matter of changing entertainment preferences. It reflects a wider problem concerning how people allocate their time and attention.

The consequences may be visible in several areas:

Reduced exposure to complex ideas and sustained arguments.

Less familiarity with history, literature, philosophy and political thought.

Greater dependence on short summaries and fragmented information.

Reduced willingness to engage with material that requires patience and intellectual effort.

A tendency to confuse familiarity with a subject with a deeper understanding of it.

However, these consequences should not be treated as inevitable or as proof that every digital reader has inferior comprehension. Digital reading can be intellectually rigorous, and printed books are not automatically a guarantee of learning.

The real distinction is between active and passive engagement with information.

A person who reads a well-researched digital book, evaluates its sources and reflects upon its arguments is engaging in serious intellectual activity. Conversely, someone who mechanically turns the pages of a printed book without understanding it is not necessarily becoming more knowledgeable.

The challenge is to restore depth, continuity and critical thinking to the reading process.

What happens when children stop reading beyond their textbooks?

An especially worrying aspect is the shrinking space for independent reading among children and young adults.

In many households, children are encouraged to study for examinations, complete assignments and obtain qualifications. Yet, reading beyond the prescribed curriculum is often considered unnecessary.

This produces a narrow understanding of education.

A student may obtain excellent marks but remain unfamiliar with the historical background of their country, the development of democratic institutions, important scientific discoveries, world literature or the ideas that shaped modern political thought.

Education without intellectual curiosity risks becoming a process of memorisation rather than understanding.

Schools should therefore make reading a regular part of everyday education. Libraries must be active learning spaces, not rooms opened only when examinations approach.

Children should be encouraged to read stories, biographies, science, history, travel writing, poetry and literature in their mother tongue as well as other languages.

A society cannot cultivate independent thinkers if its children are never encouraged to think beyond the syllabus.

The danger is not that the younger generation is reading on screens instead of paper. The danger is that it may gradually lose the habit of reading anything that demands sustained thought.

8. The preservation crisis: Digitise before time destroys what neglect has spared

One of the most serious responsibilities of libraries is the preservation of old books, manuscripts, newspapers, government reports, gazetteers, administrative records and historical documents.

Paper is a vulnerable medium. It deteriorates because of humidity, temperature fluctuations, insects, fungal growth, acidic paper, inappropriate storage, mishandling and natural ageing.

Palm-leaf manuscripts, handwritten records and nineteenth-century printed documents are particularly vulnerable.

A document may survive for 150 years and then become unreadable within a few decades if it is stored under unsuitable conditions.

This is where modern technology offers an opportunity that previous generations never possessed.

Digitisation can preserve the intellectual content of a document and make it accessible to researchers without requiring repeated handling of fragile originals.

The National Library of India, the Asiatic Society, Khuda Bakhsh Oriental Public Library and other institutions have undertaken digitisation and conservation initiatives. The Asiatic Society, for example, reports digitisation of thousands of manuscripts and the creation of associated metadata.

However, digitisation must be approached as a systematic national programme rather than a collection of isolated projects.

What should the government do?

India needs a National Programme for the Digitisation and Preservation of Historical Knowledge, covering both central and state institutions.

The programme should include the following measures:

1. Complete digitisation of rare collections

Every rare manuscript, historical book, government gazette, settlement report, census record, administrative publication and archival document should be systematically digitised.

Priority should be given to documents that are fragile, unique, historically significant or at risk of deterioration.

2. High-quality digital preservation

Scanning alone is insufficient. Documents must be captured at archival quality, with colour accuracy, high resolution and appropriate metadata.

Original files should be retained in preservation-grade formats, with accessible derivatives for public use.

3. Multiple backups and disaster recovery

Digital collections must be maintained in geographically separated locations, with secure backups, integrity checks and regular migration to current storage systems.

A digitised collection that disappears because of a server failure is no better than a destroyed physical archive.

4. Searchable text and multilingual access

Optical Character Recognition (OCR) should make digitised documents searchable. Special attention must be given to Indian scripts, historical typography and handwritten manuscripts, where automated recognition remains challenging.

5. A national digital library gateway

The Ministry of Culture should develop an integrated portal through which citizens, students and researchers can discover the collections of national, state and specialised libraries.

A researcher should be able to search historical gazettes, government publications and rare books across institutions without having to travel from one city to another.

6. Conservation laboratories and trained personnel

Digitisation cannot replace physical preservation. Fragile manuscripts require scientific conservation, controlled temperature and humidity, pest management, acid-free storage and trained conservators.

7. Public access and research use

Where copyright and other legal restrictions permit, digitised material should be freely available to the public.

Historical government publications and out-of-copyright works should not be unnecessarily hidden behind institutional barriers.

8. Institutional accountability

Every major library should publish annual information about the condition of its collection, the number of documents digitised, restoration work undertaken, public access, research usage and expenditure.

These measures should be supported by the Ministry of Culture, the National Archives of India, the National Library, state governments, universities and relevant scientific institutions.

Digital preservation is not a substitute for physical libraries

There is a temptation to assume that once books are digitised, physical libraries become less important.

That would be a serious mistake.

A manuscript has physical and historical characteristics that a digital image cannot fully reproduce. Its paper, ink, handwriting, annotations, binding, provenance and marginalia may themselves contain historical evidence.

A digital copy can preserve the readable content, but it cannot always preserve every aspect of the original object.

Moreover, physical libraries offer an environment conducive to concentration, discovery, discussion and intellectual engagement.

Digitisation should therefore complement physical preservation, not replace it.

We must preserve the original, create its digital counterpart and ensure that both remain accessible to generations that will study our history long after we are gone.

9. The responsibility of government: Libraries are essential public infrastructure

The Central Secretariat Library controversy raises an important question about the priorities of public administration.

Government departments spend enormous sums on buildings, roads, office complexes, ceremonial infrastructure, technology and administrative expansion. Such expenditure may be necessary, but the question is whether the institutions responsible for preserving the nation's knowledge receive comparable attention.

A government that demolishes an old office complex in the name of modernisation has an obligation to ensure that the institutions housed within it are relocated with dignity, adequate space and improved facilities.

It is particularly ironic that an institution under the Ministry of Culture, whose very purpose includes preservation of India's cultural and intellectual inheritance, should have faced uncertainty over its accommodation.

The fact that the Supreme Court had to intervene to secure a serious response from the authorities exposes a failure of administrative foresight.

The judiciary should not have to remind the executive that books and historical collections deserve respect.

The government's responsibility does not end with providing a building. It must ensure that the new accommodation meets the actual requirements of the institution.

In the case of the Central Secretariat Library, this means examining several issues:

Whether the allocated space can accommodate the entire existing collection, including books held at other locations.

Whether the proposed storage arrangements meet archival preservation standards.

Whether adequate space exists for reading rooms, reference sections and research facilities.

Whether the library will have suitable infrastructure for digitisation and conservation.

Whether its location will remain convenient for government officials, researchers, students and ordinary readers.

Whether future acquisitions and expansion have been adequately considered.

The difference between the library's existing area and the reported new allocation must be assessed through a proper architectural and functional plan. A nominal assurance that all books will fit is not a substitute for a technically verified assessment.

The government should also make the final layout and preservation arrangements available to the Supreme Court and the public.

The allocation of approximately 4,000 square metres is a welcome development, but it should be regarded as the beginning of a more comprehensive solution.

The larger contradiction in India's development priorities

India aspires to become a knowledge economy, a global centre of research, innovation, artificial intelligence, scientific discovery and technological development.

Yet, the development of a knowledge economy cannot be reduced to constructing data centres, establishing technology parks or purchasing advanced equipment.

Its foundation must be a population capable of reading, understanding, questioning, researching and producing knowledge.

A country cannot become intellectually powerful merely by importing technology. It must cultivate the capacity to understand, improve and create it.

That requires schools with functioning libraries, universities with strong research collections, accessible public libraries, well-funded archives and a culture that values reading.

The government must recognise that libraries are not expenditure without returns. Their benefits accumulate across generations.

A child who discovers the pleasure of reading may become a scientist, teacher, administrator, writer, entrepreneur or socially conscious citizen.

A researcher who gains access to an old government report may uncover a historical fact that changes our understanding of an entire period.

A policymaker who consults earlier reports may avoid repeating an administrative mistake.

The economic and social returns of libraries are therefore difficult to capture through conventional annual financial calculations.

Their value lies in the intellectual capacities they help create.

10. What India must do to revive its reading culture

Preserving existing libraries is only one part of the challenge. The country must also create new readers.

A library is meaningful only when people enter it, borrow its books, use its resources and develop an enduring relationship with reading.

India requires a national effort to make reading an everyday social habit.

The following measures deserve priority.

First, every school must have a functioning library.

A library should be a compulsory component of educational infrastructure, with age-appropriate books in local languages, English and Hindi, trained librarians and regular reading periods.

It should not be treated as a room that can be converted into a classroom or storage facility whenever space becomes scarce.

Second, every district should have a modern public library.

District libraries should function as knowledge centres, providing books, newspapers, digital resources, internet access, reference services, competitive examination material and dedicated children's reading spaces.

Third, rural libraries should be revived.

Village-level libraries, mobile libraries and community reading centres can extend access to people who cannot travel to district headquarters.

Ranganathan's experiment with bullock-cart libraries offers a valuable historical example of taking books to readers instead of expecting every reader to travel to a library.

Fourth, libraries should become community institutions.

Reading clubs, author interactions, book discussions, literary events, storytelling sessions, science demonstrations and public lectures can make libraries active centres of community life.

Fifth, governments should promote reading in regional languages.

Literary and scientific material must be available in Hindi, Punjabi, Tamil, Bengali, Marathi, Malayalam and other Indian languages. A public library should not become inaccessible to a reader simply because their preferred language is different from English.

Sixth, public libraries should provide digital facilities.

Computer terminals, digital catalogues, e-books, online journals, educational databases and access to government information should become standard features.

Seventh, libraries should be accessible to marginalised communities.

Persons with disabilities, economically disadvantaged students, women, senior citizens and people living in remote areas should have equal access to library services.

Eighth, reading should become a public policy priority.

National and state governments should establish measurable targets for library membership, reading participation, books issued, children's reading levels and digital access.

The objective should not be to build more buildings merely for statistical achievement. It should be to develop more readers.

11. A library is the conscience of a civilised society

There is a deeper philosophical dimension to this discussion.

A civilised society is not defined exclusively by the wealth it accumulates, the monuments it constructs, the size of its economy or the strength of its military.

It is also defined by the knowledge it preserves, the questions it permits its citizens to ask and the intellectual freedom it makes possible.

Libraries provide a space where ideas can exist without being required to justify their immediate commercial or political usefulness.

A person can read Karl Marx without becoming a Marxist, Adam Smith without becoming a capitalist, Gandhi without agreeing with every aspect of Gandhian thought, or Ambedkar without accepting every political position associated with his followers.

That is the beauty of a library.

It does not demand ideological conformity. It offers intellectual possibilities.

A student can compare different interpretations of history. A citizen can examine government decisions. A researcher can question established conclusions. A young person can encounter ideas that may fundamentally alter their understanding of society.

In a healthy democracy, this freedom is indispensable.

The availability of books also helps citizens distinguish between information and propaganda, evidence and assertion, historical fact and political mythology.

A society that reads widely is better equipped to examine public claims critically. Reading alone does not guarantee wisdom or democratic values, but a strong reading culture creates conditions in which independent judgement can develop.

The responsibility of a government, therefore, is not merely to maintain libraries but to protect the institutional conditions that allow knowledge to circulate freely.

It must encourage intellectual curiosity rather than discourage questioning.

It must preserve historical records even when those records contain uncomfortable truths about the past.

It must make public knowledge accessible irrespective of the political, economic or social background of the reader.

A library is one of the few public institutions where a poor citizen can sit beside a powerful official and both can access the same intellectual inheritance.

That equality is worth protecting.

12. Conclusion: What will we leave behind for the next generation?

The controversy surrounding the Central Secretariat Library should become an occasion for a much wider national debate.

The 4,000-square-metre allocation at Netaji Nagar is a welcome step, but the larger issue remains unresolved. The country must decide whether its historic libraries will be treated as inconvenient administrative assets or as permanent repositories of national knowledge.

A library containing 8.5 lakh books is not simply a collection of old publications. It represents the accumulated experience, observations, research and administrative memory of generations.

Its records allow future generations to understand the past without depending entirely upon the interpretations of those who write about it.

If such material is destroyed, neglected or rendered inaccessible, the loss is not confined to the institution. It becomes a loss for the entire country.

The irony is that India has never lacked great scholars, philosophers, writers or traditions of learning. It has produced intellectual traditions that influenced societies far beyond its geographical boundaries.

Yet, the country continues to struggle with the basic task of providing accessible, adequately funded and professionally managed libraries to its citizens.

The figures concerning public libraries in Haryana and Punjab, the declining leisure-reading trend and the uncertainty surrounding the Central Secretariat Library should all serve as warnings.

We must ask ourselves what kind of intellectual inheritance we intend to leave behind.

Will future generations inherit a country with magnificent buildings but neglected libraries? Will they find historical documents preserved in searchable digital archives, or discover that irreplaceable records have disappeared because nobody considered their preservation urgent?

Will children grow up with books as companions, or will their intellectual world increasingly be restricted to fragmented information delivered through screens?

These are not questions about nostalgia for printed books. They are questions about the future of education, democracy, historical understanding and intellectual independence.

Technology will continue to evolve. Reading devices will become more sophisticated, artificial intelligence will transform access to information and new forms of communication will emerge.

But the fundamental need to read, think, question and understand will remain.

A society that stops reading gradually becomes dependent upon others to interpret the world for it. It loses the patience to examine arguments and the confidence to question established narratives.

That is an intellectual impoverishment no amount of economic growth can compensate for.

The government must therefore go beyond relocating the Central Secretariat Library. It must modernise the institution, digitise its holdings, preserve its rare collections and make its resources more accessible to the public.

It must also launch a serious national programme to strengthen public libraries, encourage reading among children and revive the culture of books.

A nation should be judged not only by the buildings it constructs for its present generation, but also by the knowledge it preserves for generations it will never meet.

Buildings are constructed to serve the living. Libraries preserve the thoughts of the dead for the unborn.

Let us not become a nation that remembers its monuments but forgets its books.

References

The following sources provide the historical, institutional and research foundation for this article.

1. Ministry of Culture, Government of India — Central Secretariat Library, official institutional history and collection details. Central Secretariat Library.

2. Ministry of Culture — National Library of India, institutional history and the development of the Calcutta Public Library and Imperial Library. National Library of India.

3. Ministry of Culture — Annual Report 2023–24, reader statistics and services of the Central Secretariat Library. Ministry of Culture Annual Report.

4. Manikant Mishra, Govt allots 4K sqm for Central Sectt Library ahead of Supreme Court hearing today, The Tribune, 20 November 2026. The Tribune report.

5. Damini Nath, After Supreme Court scrutiny, Centre raises library allocation from 300 to 4,000 sq m, The Indian Express, November 2026. The Indian Express report.

6. Supreme Court proceedings reported by Ananthakrishnan G, Show some respect to books: Court to Centre on plan to move heritage library, The Indian Express, 16 November 2026. Supreme Court proceedings.

7. Kim Ryholt and Gojko Barjamovic (eds.), Libraries before Alexandria: Ancient Near Eastern Traditions, Oxford University Press, 2019. Oxford Academic.

8. S. R. Ranganathan, The Five Laws of Library Science, Madras Library Association, 1931.

9. UCL, A Reading Revolution: S. R. Ranganathan, the Father of Library Science. University College London.

10. Friedrich Engels and Karl Marx historical biography, Karl Marx House Museum, Short Biography of Karl Marx. Karl Marx biography.

11. NCAER, Palash Baruah and D. L. Wankhar, India's Reading Class Is Shrinking, 2 February 2026. NCAER research.

12. Ministry of Culture, National Mission on Libraries Strengthens Public Library Network all over the country, Press Information Bureau, 15 December 2025. PIB release.

13. Library of Congress, Annual Report of the Librarian of Congress, FY2024. Annual report.

14. British Library, Growing Knowledge: Strategy 2026–2032. British Library strategy.

15. Ministry of Culture, Government of India — Rampur Raza Library, Khuda Bakhsh Oriental Public Library, Sarasvati Mahal Library and Connemara Public Library. Rampur Raza Library; Khuda Bakhsh Library; Sarasvati Mahal Library; Connemara Public Library.


 

No comments: